Clinics of Conservative Dental Medicine · Years 4-5 · Medical University of Sofia

01

Dental caries - classifications. Basic principles for the establishment and critical analysis of existing classifications

Free notes for topic 01 of the Clinics of Conservative Dental Medicine syllabus, open without an account. Written by a senior student against the syllabus question and checked line by line by a second student before publishing. How content is made

Updated

Summary

note

Dental caries is a disease of the hard tissues of the tooth. Localised demineralisation of the inorganic part and destruction of the organic substances lead, often, to cavitation. Caries has been classified in many ways: by location on the tooth, by the size of the lesion and how far it reaches towards the pulp, by the tissue affected, by the time of appearance, by activity, by severity, by speed of progression, by pathomorphology, and by the WHO and ICDAS detection systems. Each system answers a different question, so no single one serves every purpose. Students should know the terms, the criteria behind each one, and the reason it was made.

1. Definition and sites of initiation

note

Karova defines dental caries as an irreversible disease of the hard structure of teeth. It is the result of localised demineralisation of the inorganic portion and destruction of the organic substances of the tooth, and it often leads to cavitation. Early lesions that have not yet cavitated are the exception to this description, and the classification below labels them reversible.

Caries develops at relatively protected sites in the dentition, where biofilms (dental plaque) are allowed to accumulate and mature over time. Lesions are found on:

  1. Pits, grooves and fissures on occlusal surfaces, especially during eruption.
  2. Smooth enamel surfaces: the proximal surfaces cervical to the contact point or area, and the surfaces along the gingival margin.
  3. Root surfaces.
  4. Areas around foreign materials or bodies placed in the dentition, such as fillings with inappropriate margins, dentures and orthodontic bands.
Five clinical photographs of sites of caries initiation: occlusal pits and fissures, a posterior tooth viewed with a mirror, anterior teeth, a smooth enamel surface and a lesion at the cervical margin near the gingiva
Five clinical photographs of sites of caries initiation: occlusal pits and fissures, a posterior tooth viewed with a mirror, anterior teeth, a smooth enamel surface and a lesion at the cervical margin near the gingiva
Schematic molar in side view with five numbered sites where caries starts: 1 pits, grooves and fissures on the occlusal surface; 2 proximal surface cervical to the contact point; 3 smooth surface along the gingival margin; 4 exposed root surface; 5 margin of a restoration
Schematic molar in side view with five numbered sites where caries starts: 1 pits, grooves and fissures on the occlusal surface; 2 proximal surface cervical to the contact point; 3 smooth surface along the gingival margin; 4 exposed root surface; 5 margin of a restoration

Basic principles of classification

note

A classification sorts lesions by one feature that matters for diagnosis, for treatment planning or for research. Karova lists these bases: the location of the lesion on the tooth, its dimension and relation to the dental pulp, the tissue affected, the time of its appearance, its activity, the severity of the process, the speed of its progression and its pathomorphological characteristics. The WHO system and the ICDAS system are later detection and assessment systems built on the same idea of grading severity.

Nine boxes, one for each basis of classification (location, size and pulp, tissue affected, time of appearance, activity, severity, speed, pathomorphology, detection codes), each with its named types
Nine boxes, one for each basis of classification (location, size and pulp, tissue affected, time of appearance, activity, severity, speed, pathomorphology, detection codes), each with its named types

Aetiology and risk factors

note

Caries is a multifactorial disease. Karova's risk assessment lists these factors: age under 18 or over 65 years, high intake of refined carbohydrates, high levels of Streptococcus mutans, poor oral hygiene, reduced salivation, a history of extensive restorations, defective restorations, tobacco and alcohol use, lack of fluoride during tooth development, family history of the disease and a lower socioeconomic status. Patients with a high risk need aggressive intervention to remove or change these factors. Patients with a low risk need regular monitoring.

Pathogenesis

note

Karova describes caries as the result of a broken balance. Caries appears when the balance between protective and pathological factors in the oral cavity is ruined. The pathological factors are reduced salivary function, cariogenic bacteria such as mutans streptococci, and frequent ingestion of carbohydrates. Control of the disease can be achieved in two ways: by reducing the demineralising factors and by increasing the protective factors.

2. Classification by location

note

Karova sorts lesions by their site on the tooth.

LocationSites
Pit and fissure cariesOcclusal surfaces of posterior teeth, where the lesion depends on the shape, morphological characteristics and depth of the pits and fissures; buccal and lingual surfaces of molars; lingual surfaces of maxillary incisors
Smooth surface cariesProximal surfaces; the gingival third of buccal and lingual surfaces
Root cariesExposed root cementum and dentine
Atypical locationLesions at sites not listed above

The shape of a pit or fissure decides how easily a lesion starts in it. Karova illustrates the four common shapes, labelled Y, U, V and I.

Four shapes of pits and fissures on an occlusal surface, labelled Y, U, V and I
Four shapes of pits and fissures on an occlusal surface, labelled Y, U, V and I

Lesions at the two sites differ in shape in section. A pit and fissure lesion has a narrow entrance and becomes progressively wider closer to the dentinoenamel junction (DEJ), giving the form of an inverted V. A smooth surface lesion is V-shaped, with a wide area of origin and its apex directed towards the DEJ.

Two cross-sections of carious lesions: A, a pit and fissure lesion with a narrow entrance widening towards the dentinoenamel junction; B, a smooth surface lesion, V-shaped, with a wide origin and its apex towards the junction
Two cross-sections of carious lesions: A, a pit and fissure lesion with a narrow entrance widening towards the dentinoenamel junction; B, a smooth surface lesion, V-shaped, with a wide origin and its apex towards the junction

3. Classification by dimension and relation to the pulp

note

The size of a lesion, and how far it has advanced towards the pulp, decides its name and its treatment.

LesionExtentNotes
Macula cariosa alba, or caries incipiens (reversibilis)Enamel demineralisation onlyChalky white, opaque spot; no cavity
Macula cariosa fuscaEnamel demineralisation with brown pigmentationUsually in pits and fissures, the foramen caecum and proximal surfaces
Caries superficialis (irreversibilis)Destruction only in enamel, not extending through the DEJDoes not cross the dentinoenamel junction
Caries mediaEngages enamel and not more than half of the dentine layerCrosses the DEJ into dentine
Caries profundaEngages enamel and more than half of the dentine layerSometimes close to the dental pulp

The early enamel lesion has a characteristic inner structure, from the surface inwards: an intact surface zone, the body of the lesion, a dark zone and a translucent zone at the advancing front.

Diagram of an early enamel lesion in section, from the surface inwards: intact surface zone, body of the lesion, dark zone and translucent zone at the advancing front
Diagram of an early enamel lesion in section, from the surface inwards: intact surface zone, body of the lesion, dark zone and translucent zone at the advancing front

Caries in dentine progresses faster than in enamel. The lesion spreads laterally and undermines the enamel, and in section it forms a cone in dentine with its point directed towards the pulp.

Diagrammatic representation of a carious lesion with occlusal caries and the clinical tactile grades of dentine from soft to hard, with the zones from necrotic to sound dentine
Diagrammatic representation of a carious lesion with occlusal caries and the clinical tactile grades of dentine from soft to hard, with the zones from necrotic to sound dentine
Four columns, one per depth: macula cariosa on the enamel surface, caries superficialis within the enamel, caries media through the dentinoenamel junction to half the dentine, and caries profunda beyond half the dentine close to the pulp
Four columns, one per depth: macula cariosa on the enamel surface, caries superficialis within the enamel, caries media through the dentinoenamel junction to half the dentine, and caries profunda beyond half the dentine close to the pulp

4. Classification by the tissue affected

note

  • Caries adamantina affects the enamel.
  • Caries eburnea affects the dentine.
  • Caries cementi affects the cementum.

Root caries involves the cementum and dentine of the exposed root.

5. Classification by time of appearance

note

  • Primary caries: lesions on unrestored surfaces.
  • Recurrent (secondary) caries: lesions developing adjacent to fillings.
  • Residual caries (caries recidiva): insufficiently excavated carious tissue, left in place before the restoration is placed.

6. Classification by activity

note

  • Active carious lesiona lesion in progress.
  • Inactive or arrested carious lesiona lesion that formed earlier but whose progression has stopped. Karova gives these signs: the cavity is large and open, the lesion no longer retains food, and it has become self-cleansing.

Karova states that treatment planning depends mostly on the activity of the lesion. The clinical indicators that separate active and inactive lesions are set out in the topic on clinical and paraclinical characteristics.

7. Classification by severity of the process

note

  • Caries simplexthe hard dental tissues are involved, without signs of pulpal inflammation.
  • Caries complicataa developed lesion involves the dental pulp, with signs of pulpal inflammation.

8. Classification by speed of progression

note

TypeSpeed and featuresTypical features
Acute cariesDevelops rapidly, usually in caries-active patientsLight-brown or grey colour; caseous consistency of carious tissue
Chronic cariesDevelops very slowly and affects fewer teethDark brown colour; leathery and hard consistency
Rampant cariesMultiple active lesions in the same patient, often on surfaces that are usually caries freeUsually due to poor oral hygiene or frequent carbohydrate intake; also due to hyposalivation or radiation therapy

Karova describes acute caries as affecting children and young adults up to the age of 25 with poor oral hygiene, and running a rapid course of about one to one and a half years, which may involve the pulp.

9. Classification by pathomorphology

note

  • Caries siccahard in consistency, dark in colour, slow in development. It is typical of chronic lesions.
  • Caries humidasoft and wet, caseous carious tissue, light in colour, with a small entrance in the enamel that makes it retentive for plaque. It develops rapidly and is typical of acute lesions.

10. WHO classification of caries lesions

note

CodeLesion
D1Clinically detectable enamel lesions with intact, non-cavitated surfaces: an opaque enamel surface (detectable only after drying in early stages) or a white-spot lesion with a slightly rough surface
D2Clinically detectable cavities limited to enamel
D3Clinically detectable cavities in dentine
D4Lesions extending into the pulp

11. ICDAS: the International Caries Detection and Assessment System

note

Karova explains that ICDAS was developed to give clinicians, epidemiologists and researchers an evidence-based system for standardised caries detection and diagnosis in different environments and situations. It was built from a systematic review of the literature on clinical caries detection systems and other sources. It records the severity and incidence of caries as a continuum. ICDAS I was developed in 2002 and modified to ICDAS II in 2005.

The coronal codes run from 0 to 6, and each code has a criterion.

CodeCriterion
0Sound tooth surface: no evidence of caries after 5 seconds of air drying
1First visual change in enamel: opacity or discolouration (white or brown) visible at the entrance to the pit or fissure after prolonged air drying
2Distinct visual change in enamel, visible when wet; the lesion must be visible when dry
3Localised enamel breakdown without clinical visual signs of dentinal involvement, seen when wet and after prolonged drying
4Underlying dark shadow from dentine
5Distinct cavity with visible dentine
6Extensive distinct cavity with visible dentine, more than half of the surface involved
Table of ICDAS codes 0 to 6 and their criteria for coronal caries, as printed in the textbook
Table of ICDAS codes 0 to 6 and their criteria for coronal caries, as printed in the textbook

Karova's summary figure pairs each ICDAS code with a clinical photograph and with a lay and a dental term. Code 0 is sound. Codes 1 and 2 are early-stage decay, codes 3 and 4 are established decay (moderate lesions) and codes 5 and 6 are severe decay (extensive lesions).

Clinical photographs and lay and dental terms for ICDAS codes 0 to 6, from no disease to extensive lesion
Clinical photographs and lay and dental terms for ICDAS codes 0 to 6, from no disease to extensive lesion

12. Root surface coding

note

Karova notes that the National Institutes of Health found insufficient evidence on the validity of clinical diagnostic systems for root caries. Root caries is frequently seen near the cementoenamel junction (CEJ), but lesions can appear anywhere on the root. Colour was once used to show whether a root lesion was active (yellowish or light brown) or arrested (darkly stained), but Karova states that colour has since been shown not to be a reliable indicator of caries activity. One score is given per root surface: the facial, mesial, distal and lingual surfaces of each tooth. Surfaces that cannot be seen directly, because of gingival recession or after gentle air drying, are excluded (code E).

CodeCriterion
ERoot surface cannot be visualised directly; excluded. Surfaces covered entirely by calculus are excluded, or the calculus is removed before the surface is scored
0No unusual discolouration and no surface defect at the CEJ or on the root; natural anatomical contour, or loss of continuity not consistent with caries
1Clearly demarcated discoloured area at the root surface or CEJ, with no cavitation (loss of anatomical contour less than 0.5 mm)
2Clearly demarcated discoloured area (light or dark brown, black) with cavitation (loss of anatomical contour of 0.5 mm or more)
Table of root surface codes E, 0, 1 and 2 for detection and classification of carious lesions on root surfaces
Table of root surface codes E, 0, 1 and 2 for detection and classification of carious lesions on root surfaces

13. Critical analysis of the existing classifications

note

The classifications differ in what they are for, and that is the basis of any critical reading.

  • Location, dimension, tissue and time describe what is seen on the tooth. They are simple to record but say little about how the lesion will behave.
  • Activity, speed and pathomorphology describe behaviour and are the basis for treatment decisions. Activity decides treatment planning, and a lesion's colour is not a reliable guide to whether it is active.
  • The WHO system and ICDAS are grading systems for detection. ICDAS was designed to be used the same way in clinics, in epidemiology and in research, so that results from different settings can be compared.
  • The root surface system is a detection code, and the National Institutes of Health found the evidence for root caries clinical systems insufficient.
  • Several categories overlap at the edges. A lesion can be called caries superficialis or caries media depending on whether it has crossed the dentinoenamel junction, and that boundary is judged clinically and radiographically rather than measured.

All 56 Clinics of Conservative Dental Medicine topics · exam study support, not clinical guidance. SuperMed is not affiliated with the Medical University of Sofia.

Start free. No card needed.

Every account starts free, with Medical Ethics, Urology and Computer Science open in full and free topics in Cytology, Latin Language, Medical Chemistry, Medical Physics, Medical Biology, Anatomy, Biophysics, Medical Psychology, MCS (Disaster Medicine), Physiology, Biochemistry, Social Medicine, Medical Genetics, General Pathology, Pharmacology, Pathophysiology, Microbiology, Internal Medicine, Nephrology, Cardiology, Pulmonology, Gastroenterology, Internal Medicine (Clinical), Obstetrics and Gynecology, Pediatrics, Forensic Medicine and Deontology, Physiotherapy and Rehabilitation, Anesthesiology and Reanimation, Dental Materials (Dental Medicine), Preclinics of Prosthetic Dental Medicine, Medical Psychology (Dental Medicine), SMME (Social Medicine & Medical Ethics), Preclinics of Pediatric Dental Medicine, Hygiene and Epidemiology, Oral Pathology, General Surgery, Preclinics of Conservative Dental Medicine, Preclinics of Oral and Maxillofacial Medicine, Dental Public Health, Clinics of Prosthetic Dental Medicine, Dental Prophylaxis, Diagnostic Imaging, Dental Allergology, Internal Diseases and Immunology, Otorhinolaryngology (Dental Medicine), Clinics of Conservative Dental Medicine, Clinics of Maxillofacial Surgery, Clinics of Pediatric Dental Medicine, Periodontology, Forensic Medicine and Deontology (Dental Medicine), Obstetrics and Gynaecology, Dental Implantology, Physiotherapy, Cytology & Histology, Medical Chemistry, Medical Physics, Anatomy I, Biophysics, Latin with Medical Terminology, Medical Biology, Biochemistry, Human Physiology, Social Medicine and Medical Ethics, Anatomy II, Microbiology, Medical Psychology, Pathophysiology, Disaster Medicine, Hygiene, Ecology and Occupational Diseases, Propaedeutics of Internal Diseases, General and Operative Surgery, Roentgenology and Radiology, Clinical Laboratory, Medical Physics (Dental Medicine), Cytology, Histology and Embryology, Human Biology (Dental Medicine), Latin and Medical Terminology, Anatomy and Histology (Dental Medicine), Chemistry (Dental Medicine), Biophysics (Dental Medicine), Dental Materials (Dental Medicine), Preclinic of Prosthetic Dentistry, Social Medicine with Medical Ethics, Biochemistry (Dental Medicine), Human Physiology (Dental Medicine), Microbiology (Dental Medicine), Pediatric Dentistry - Part I, Medical Psychology (Dental Medicine), Pathoanatomy (Dental Medicine), Dental Prevention, Pathophysiology (Dental Medicine), Conservative Dentistry - Part I, Special Surgery, including Local Anaesthesia and Analgesics in Dental Medicine, Human Biology, Physics, Chemistry, Latin Language with Medical Terminology, Anatomy and Histology, Cytology, General Histology and Human Embryology, Biophysics, Social Medicine and Biostatistics, Biochemistry, Human Physiology, Disaster Medicine, Pathophysiology, General Pathology, Hygiene and Ecology, Medical Psychology, Chemistry (Dental Medicine), Physics and Biophysics, Cytology, General Histology and Human Embryology (Dental Medicine), Human Biology, Human Genetics and Regenerative Medicine, Latin Language (Dental Medicine), Computer Technique, Dental Materials (Dental Medicine), Dental Morphology, Occlusion and Function of the Jaws, Anatomy and Human Histology, Biochemistry (Dental Medicine), Pre-clinics of Pediatric Dentistry, Human Physiology (Dental Medicine), Social Medicine and Medical Ethics (Dental Medicine), Medical Psychology (Dental Medicine), Disaster Medicine (Dental Medicine), Propaedeutics of Conservative Dentistry, Pharmacology (Dental Medicine), Pathophysiology (Dental Medicine), Pathoanatomy (Dental Medicine), Hygiene, Preventive Medicine and Epidemiology, Anaesthesiology and Emergencies, Otorhinolaryngology (Dental Medicine), Propaedeutics of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery and Local Anaesthesia, Public Dental Health, Cytology, General Histology and Human Embryology, Physics, Chemistry, Biology, Latin Language with Medical Terminology, Human Anatomy, Biophysics, Physiology, Biochemistry, Medical Psychology, Medical Informatics, Social Medicine, Microbiology, Medical Ethics, Pathophysiology, Medical Statistics, Communication Skills, General and Operative Surgery, Propaedeutics of Internal Diseases, Medical Genetics, Hygiene, Ecology and Occupational Diseases, Radiology, Disaster Medicine, Ophthalmology and Clinical Laboratory. Super opens the rest. Super is €14.99 a month.

Create a free account